Friday, November 6, 2015

The Review That Was to Be, But Wasn't (part 2)

If Lauren Monroe can be described in one word, persistent would be it.  Over a year ago, the Montour native approached me with the first in her Maryland Shores romance series for a review.  The PG agreed to it and I wrote it.  It was never published.  Lauren approached me, the books editor, the managing editor relentlessly without luck.  I am not so sure this was a good plan on her part.  However, I was told that the remains of my work on file would be printed before the end of 2014, and they weren't.  I tried to find another publication to print them, but had no luck myself.  So, because I like to keep a promise if I can,  and in this case, I couldn't, I am printing the review here.  By the way, Lauren has written a second book in the series, Second Chances, and for readers of books series along the lines of Debbie Macomber or Susan Wiggs, and who enjoy a Pittsburgh connection, you may want to give the series a try.  As for now, here are my thoughts on the first book in the series:

********



Montour High School graduate and former Monroeville resident, Loriann Oberlin, has moved to the Chesapeake area and published her first novel, Letting Go under the pen name of Lauren Monroe.  This romance novel is the story of a young widow, Maren Mitchell, who meets and falls in love with a young surgeon, Dr. Steve Kramer , when her son undergoes an emergency appendectomy.  The story takes place at a difficult time in the DC/Maryland area:  a year after 9/11 and during the time of the I-95 sniper attacks.  Maren, who lost her husband in an auto accident 16 months prior, is attempting to open her own graphic design business when an offer comes from the hospital that Dr. Steve works in.  He encourages her to interview and accept.  As time goes on, their relationship grows.
Monroe shares the beauty of the Chesapeake area with her readers and intentionally brings a bit of the ‘burgh into the story.  Taking place in the fall, some of the book’s action takes place on Steve’s  large power boat and a sailboat belonging to Maren’s father.  Steve and best friend, Dr. Paul Romano, attended UPMC medical school.  Dr. Romano is a native Pittsburgher, and a lover of the Strip District, biscotti and Sunday gravy.  Both men are Steelers fans and the story follows the Steelers season, led by  quarterbacks Kordell Stewart and Tommy Maddox .  Terrible towels and the black and gold (vs. purple and black) get  plenty of attention.
The story behind  Letting Go had its roots in the 1990’s  before the author’s move to Maryland.  A practicing counselor with a masters degree from John Hopkins, Monroe has written nine non-fiction  books as well.  Her most recent non-fiction book is Overcoming Passive-Aggression.  She also taught creative writing at locally at community college campuses  and at Pitt’s Informal Program.  Monroe revisited her original story, and hoped to update the story to reflect her life experiences as well as to write fiction rather than a journalistic style that she had been accustomed to in her local work.
Letting Go has both strengths and weaknesses.   Character development is strong .  We know that Maren has had anxiety and difficulty adjusting to her husband’s tragic death.  She hates hospitals.  It is a challenge for her to not call for support while her son undergoes his appendectomy in the same hospital that her husband died in.   We learn that Steve, at the age of 39, has become chief of surgery due to his perseverance  in attending both the University of Pittsburgh’s medical school and Columbia University.  He also is alone, and has some secrets that he doesn’t wish to share with Maren.  However, his ability to capture not just her heart, but her son’s and her parents,  overshadows the past he chooses not to share.  Maren’s son , Dylan, is a typical 6-year-old and endearing.   Her parents, and Steve’s as well, are likable and open.   In contrast, Maren’s former in-laws and Steve’s past love interests are almost caricatures of the extremely  evil girlfriend and the extreme bimbo girlfriend.
The challenge to reading Letting Go is not the realistic story or the characters, but in the flow of the writing complicated by the attempt to bring Pittsburgh into the story.   I found much of the dialogue hard to follow and that I was missing the point.  Using Pittsburghese fell flat.  Dr. Paul uses “Yinz,” and  the phrase “redd up” is explained in the story, but only Western Pennsylvanian readers will care and perhaps not in a positive way.  And really, do outsiders honestly believe that the Strip district is a red light district?  I just didn’t feel that we were portrayed in as positive a light as Monroe hoped we would be.  
Letting Go may appeal to light romance readers who are not looking for any reading that is too intense.   As the first in a planned series under the header, The Maryland Shores,  the novel  falls short.  I will often continue with a series that is not a favorite because I care how the characters fare as they move on.  In this case, now that these two have resolved their storyline, I think I can let this series go.